Senate Moves Alito Close to Confirmation
2006-01-30

Category Time Year Nations U.S. States West Virginia Vermont South Dakota Rhode Island North Dakota Nebraska Virginia Massachusetts People Mitch McConnell Kent Conrad Lincoln Chafee Maria Cantwell Samuel Alito John Kerry Category U.S. Democrat Party Category U.S. Supreme Court Category 2007

The Senate on Monday all but guaranteed Samuel Alito's confirmation as the nation's 110th Supreme Court justice, shutting down a last-minute attempt by liberals to block the conservative judge's nomination with a filibuster.

Republican and Democratic senators, on a 72-25 vote, agreed to end their debate, setting up a Tuesday morning vote on Alito's confirmation to replace retiring moderate Justice Sandra Day O'Connor.

"I am pleased that a strong, bipartisan majority in the Senate decisively rejected attempts to obstruct and filibuster an up-or-down vote on Judge Sam Alito's nomination," President Bush said.

With at least 57 votes committed to Alito -- 53 Republicans and four Democrats -- approval by majority vote in the 100-member Senate seemed assured.

A bloc of Democrats, led by Massachusetts Sens. Edward Kennedy and John Kerry, unsuccessfully tried over the weekend and Monday to persuade other senators to use a vote-delaying filibuster to stop Alito, a 15-year veteran of the U.S. Appeals Court and a former lawyer for the Reagan administration.

"It is the only way we can stop a confirmation that we feel certain will cause irreversible damage to our country," said Kerry, the Democrats' 2004 presidential nominee.

O'Connor has been a swing vote on abortion rights, affirmative action, the death penalty and other contentious issues.

Alito's supporters needed 60 votes to block the filibuster, and they were joined by 13 Democrats who have announced they will vote against confirming his nomination.

"I believe that Judge Alito's nomination, if approved by the Senate, would tilt that court in a direction that will restrict personal freedoms, strengthen the role of government and corporations in our lives, and allow the expansion of power of the presidency," said Sen. Byron Dorgan (news, bio, voting record), D-N.D., who announced he would oppose Alito after voting to end debate.

"I find it regrettable that there are those who are trying to resurrect a filibuster even as there is clearly nothing in the record that constitutes extraordinary circumstances," said GOP Sen. Olympia Snowe (news, bio, voting record) of Maine, the only Republican who is publicly undecided on Alito's nomination.

Sen. Lincoln Chafee (news, bio, voting record) of Rhode Island, the only Republican to announce he will vote against Alito, also refused to support the filibuster attempt. "How are we going to get anything done if we can't work together?" Chafee asked.

Other Republicans also criticized the attempt to keep Alito from getting a confirmation vote on Tuesday before Bush's State of the Union address.

"If this hyperpoliticization of this judicial confirmation process continues, I fear in this moment we will institutionalize this behavior and someday we will be hard pressed not to employ political tests and tactics against the Supreme Court nominee of a Democratic president," said Senate Majority Whip Mitch McConnell, R-Ky.

"We saw no reason for the members of this group to support a filibuster," said senior Democratic Sen. Robert Byrd (news, bio, voting record) of West Virginia, a member of the "Gang of 14" -- a group of Republicans and Democrats who have pledged not to filibuster unless there are "extraordinary circumstances."

At least 53 of the Republicans' 55-member majority and four Democrats -- Byrd, Tim Johnson of South Dakota, Kent Conrad of North Dakota and Ben Nelson of Nebraska -- already publicly support Alito's confirmation.

Chafee, independent Sen. Jim Jeffords of Vermont, and most of the rest of the Democrats are expected to vote against Alito.

Alito hasn't stopped trying to gain more support. He visited with Sen. Maria Cantwell (news, bio, voting record), D-Wash., on Monday before the filibuster vote in hopes of getting her vote.

Cantwell said later that she would oppose him. "Judge Alito has a record of concern when it comes to placing and consolidating the rights of the government over the rights of the individual, and he has not provided the answers to adequately reassure the people of our nation," she said.

___

On the Net:

Senate: http://www.senate.gov

White House: http://www.whitehouse.gov

Supreme Court: http://www.supremecourtus.gov